Monday, October 25, 2010

Chapter 7 Reflection

Bryan Kidd
Strategy Reflection
Marzano Chapter 7
Strategy: Cooperative Learning

Part 1: Summary

            Chapter seven offers various generalizations and rules to follow to maximize learning when using cooperative learning.  Marzano admits that cooperative learning has evolved over time from various other grouping strategies and has had its challenges.  In order to get the most out of cooperative learning, Marzano points to five elements that must be present in order for it to be effective.  First, there must be positive interdependence where students understand that the group lives and dies as one.  Second, there should be face to face promotive interaction where students learn from each other.  Third, there must be individual as well as group accountability.  Fourth, it should promote interpersonal and small group skills which helps them become better decision makers.  Lastly, there should be group processing in which students reflect on their groups performance.  In conjunction with these five elements, Marzano includes three generalizations to guide cooperative learning activities.  The first generalization is that grouping based on ability levels should only be done sparingly.  Low ability students tend to perform much worse with their equals while high ability students tend to have very small positive effects on one another.  The second generalization is that groups should be small.  The last generalization is that cooperative learning should be used consistently and systematically but not overdone.

Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class

            In connecting this reading to another done in class, the closest thing I found was in chapter eight of Marzano’s book which talks about setting objectives and providing feedback.  Although this chapter does not talk about objectives or feedback, what I found was similar was its emphasis on diverse learners and the need to mix things up for students.  Chapter eight discusses at length about the need to empower students to make choices about their goals and differentiate instruction so that they learn in the way they feel most comfortable.  In chapter seven, Marzano also discusses how students should be allowed to make choices on groups and how much cooperative learning activities should be done.  Essentially, both chapters highlight the need to mix up instruction strategies and empower students.

Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests

            In my clinical, the teacher I’m observing places a heavy emphasis on group work and student involvement.  Also, the material discussed in the psychology class generates a lot of student interest and involvement.  Therefore, this chapter is going to help me out quite a bit.  I intend on using cooperative learning in groups for discussions on the aging process and how teenagers change over time.  The groups I will use will likely remain similar to the ones my teacher has them in now.  He has set them up into base groups that are supposed to remain the same for the whole semester.  However, I will see if my teacher will be open for me integrating an equal amount of boys and girls into groups because it should generate more lively discussions.

Chapter 4 Reflection

Bryan Kidd
Strategy Reflection
Marzano Chapter 4
Strategy: Reinforcing Effort and Providing Feedback

Part 1:  Summary

                In chapter four, Marzano outlines the importance of a student’s connection between effort and achievement while also offering effective recognition strategies by teachers.  Generally speaking, students attribute their success in the classroom to either one of four major beliefs: their ability, their effort, other people, or luck.  When students believe that they achieve based upon their own ability, they feel bulletproof and ready to tackle any project.  When they attribute their success to effort, they have something tangible they can use when tackling assignments.  When students believe that other people or luck are the reasons they do well then it can have an obvious negative impact when those students do work on their own.  Marzano particularly gives emphasis on getting students to believe that effort has the biggest impact upon achievement.  Teachers should teach this concept as often as possible.  Through personal stories or through examples, students should regularly be reminded that hard work pays off in the end.  Teachers can talk about it directly or they can get students to track their own increases in effort and success through rubrics and charts.  Concurrently, students should receive recognition regularly when they are successful.  However, as Marzano points out there have been numerous studies that indicate that recognition has a very little and sometimes even negative impact on student achievement.  That is why it is important that teachers do so in appropriate ways.  Rewards do not necessarily negatively impact intrinsic motivation but they are much more effective when they remain attached to some form of standard performance.  Also, students prefer abstract symbolic recognition better than tangible rewards.  Furthermore, praise should be appropriate for the task achieved.  Some students respond negatively what they feel as undeserved praise.

Part 2:  Connection of reading to another reading in class

            Chapter four reminded me a lot of chapter eight in which Marzano talks at length about student feedback as well.  Although it this is a different type of feedback, it reminds me of the importance of constant interaction between the teacher and the students in mostly informal evaluations.  Whether it is advice on how to do better on a certain subject or giving the students proper praise, both are informal assessments designed to foster student motivation and effort.  Essentially, both chapters placed a high emphasis on continual assessments that help guide students and considerable engagement that helps keep students motivated.

Part 3:  Application of reading to my own teaching interests

            I have been in classrooms in which tangible rewards were a lot of fun and it got students engaged in lessons in the moment.  However, once we left class there was no reason or desire to stay engaged in our spare time.  On the other hand, I have been in classes where verbal praise and high expectations generated a desire to remain at an elevated status in the eyes of the professor.  Therefore, in my classrooms I intend to use more abstract verbal praises and essentially set high expectations for my students.  Generally, people tend to rise to the occasion.

Monday, October 4, 2010

Chapter 5 Reflection

Bryan Kidd
Strategy Reflection
Marzano Chapter 5
Strategy: Homework and Practice

Part 1:  Summary

            In chapter five, Marzano outlines numerous generalizations for practical implication of homework for students in the modern classroom.  Marzano holds that homework is a staple of past and present schools but there are ways to maximize its effectiveness in student learning.  In looking at past research, four generalizations were drawn up: the amount of homework and its effectiveness on student learning is tiered by age, parent involvement in homework should remain minimal, the homework assigned should have a clear purpose, and feedback must be given.  According to research, the younger students are the less impact homework has on their achievement.  Students should be given more as they move up in grades but homework before the second grade is seen as ineffective.  Also, parents should be involved in homework but they should not answer questions for their children when they don’t understand the fundamental concepts.  Also, homework should have a clearly defined purpose so the students and parents understand classroom policy and its importance.  When assigning homework, teachers need to identify whether or not it is designed to further practice a skill they are familiar with or if it is designed to prepare and elaborate on material that will be introduced.  If a student is given homework to practice a skill that they are unfamiliar with, then it is likely they will get frustrated and learn little.  Lastly, teachers must give some feedback on the work.  Feedback shows the students that it is important to the teacher and it helps them improve upon the skill.  Research also states that a reasonable amount of focused practice is needed to master a skill.  However, students typically go through a shaping phase when learning new skills and they shouldn’t be flooded with too much practice while they are internalizing the reasoning processes.

Part 2:  Connection of reading to another reading in class

            Although there was no other reading assigned for this week, when I read this chapter it reminded me a lot of chapter six when Marzano discussed nonlinguistic representations.  Obviously, these are not the same teaching strategies but what seemed similar to me was the fact that both offered numerous generalizations when approaching them.  It just reminded me of how flexible teaching is and how it is up to the educator to be essentially a chameleon in the classroom and adapt to the learning styles of their students after assessing their capabilities.

Part 3:  Application of reading to my own teaching interests

            Homework is really unavoidable considering the time constraints of the classroom and objectives that need to be met.  I plan on teaching high school so homework is going to play a big role.  However, what stood out to me was making sure that the purpose of the homework was clearly understood by the students and that their parents understood homework policy.  As a long time history student myself, the most annoying thing a teacher/professor can do is assign a lot of homework for seemingly no purpose.  By defining exactly what I want my students to learn they will understand that everything we do has a purpose and it is for their growth.

Monday, September 27, 2010

Chapter 6 Reflection

Bryan Kidd
Strategy Reflection
Marzano Chapter 6
Strategy: Nonlinguistic Representations

Part 1: Summary

            Chapter six essentially elaborates on the manner in which knowledge is stored.  Marzano states that people store knowledge in two ways: linguistically or in imagery form.  Traditionally, students are given information to be stored in linguistic format.   However, chapter six expands upon how knowledge can be deepened with the use of nonlinguistic practices.  There are two generalizations that can be drawn up when using nonlinguistic approaches in the classroom.  The first generalization is that it should elaborate on existing knowledge.  Students should already have a fundamental understanding of what’s being discussed because nonlinguistic approaches are intended to deepen existing understanding.  The second generalization is that there are a variety of ways to go about implementing nonlinguistic strategies.  Students can create graphic organizers, make physical models, generate mental pictures, draw pictures and pictographs, and engaging in kinesthetic activity.  Graphic organizers are the most commonly used because there are several ways to go about doing them.  Graphic organizers can take on a variety of patterns including: descriptive, time-sequence, process cause-effect, episode, generalization, and concept.  Physical models show concrete learning by the students.  Generating mental pictures gives the students general information and lets them create a personalized picture.  Drawing pictures is a simple way for the students to be creative and to get visual representation.  Kinesthetic activity allows students to combine physical movement with existing knowledge which also generates a picture.  In all, there are a variety of ways to supplement the students existing linguistic knowledge with a diverse selection of nonlinguistic approaches.

Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class

            When connecting chapter six with another reading in class, it made me think of chapter two when Marzano discussed the various approaches to identifying similarities and differences.  The connection for me was that, in both cases, Marzano emphasizes the flexibility of the educator in the manner in which material is presented.  The number of strategies seems endless and in both cases the teacher needs to identify how their student’s learn best and then find those strategies that are best suited for their class.  Another major connection between the two is that Marzano heavily emphasizes the use of graphic organizers.  Obviously, visual representation plays a major role in student learning but it appears that the use of graphic organizers tends to be more malleable and widely used.

Part 3:  Application of reading to my own teaching interests

            It is obvious to everyone that we are visual creatures and we learn better when we can picture it because we think in pictures.  In the field of social-studies, I see this being utilized extensively because what most students hate about existing classrooms is reading and note taking.  I intend to use a variety of methods from videos to a number of graphic organizers such as timelines and cause-effect patterns for historical events and maps for geography.

Chapter 3 Reflection

Bryan Kidd
Strategy Reflection
Marzano Chapter 3
Strategy: Summarizing and Note Taking

Part 1:  Summary

            Chapter three lays out several generalizations for improving two of the most important educational skills: summarization and note taking.  When summarizing, three useful generalizations have been produced by research to help students improve.  First, students must delete, substitute, and keep some information.  Essentially, students must evaluate the material and be able to identify what’s important, keep it, and substitute specifics for more general terms.  Second, students must analyze deeply so that they can synthesize the material which can have powerful effects.  Lastly, students should understand the structure of information so that they know where it is to be found and how to summarize it.  A couple of summarization strategies are offered such as the Rule Based Strategy which essentially calls for students to be concise by deleting trivial information and using broader terms.  Also, Summary Frames are offered which essentially narrows the information that is to be looked for into the subgroups: narrative, topic restriction, definition, argumentation, problem/solution, and conversation.  In regards to note taking, there were four generalizations drawn up to help students.  First, taking notes verbatim is the worst because it leaves no time for evaluation.  Second, notes should be a work in progress because taking time to review and revise deepens learning.  Third, notes should be used before tests because they are powerful review tools.  Lastly, the more notes a student takes the better.

Part 2:  Connection to another reading in class

            In connecting this reading with another in class, I was forced to do a little searching but found many connections between chapter three in Classroom Instruction and chapter two in the Art and Science.  In chapter two of Art and Science, Marzano similarly calls for students and teachers alike to prioritize information.  He states that too much information can result in too much information for students to digest and they subsequently miss the key points.  Also, Marzano states that students should take the time to revise and review in both chapters.  Furthermore, he states that they should learn through each other.  In Classroom Instruction he emphasizes reciprocal learning whereas in Art and Science he also mentions reciprocal learning but also provides a practical explanation of how a specific group strategy would work.  Essentially, he divided up a room into groups and gave each of them a piece of the puzzle to summarize and then they would explain their piece to the class and learn from one another.

Part 3:  Application of reading to my own teaching interests

            Note taking and summarizing have historically been the twin foundation of learning in a history classroom throughout my educational experience.  Taking notes from professor lectures, readings, and then subsequently summarizing this information into essays or abstracts.  In my teaching, I believe Marzano’s emphasis on group/reciprocal teaching will be highly beneficial.  I won’t attempt to overload them with information but let them teach each other.  Also, I like the idea of teacher produced notes to help the students know how to take them.

Monday, September 13, 2010

Chapter 2 Post

Bryan Kidd


Strategy Reflection

Marzano Chapter 2

Strategy: Identifying Similarities and Differences



Part 1: Summary



In chapter 2, Marzano discusses the practice of using similarities and differences to increase student knowledge and the various methods used within this practice. By comparing, students understand the parallels and contradictions between things and ideas and come to a better understanding of every variable’s composition. In doing so, Marzano breaks down four ways that students can do this at progressively improving skill sets. Students can begin by simply comparing two things to one another. The next step is classifying things into groups based upon their composition. Students can create metaphors to show patterns between separate topics. Lastly, students can create analogies which identify parallels between concepts. Although there is a plethora of methods within these four categories, they all really fall under two separate approaches: teacher-directed and student-directed. In essence, the teacher will take center stage when he/she has specific relationships that they want their students to know. When findings are broad and ambiguous, the teacher allows students to generate various findings. In using this framework, Marzano insists on the use of several graphic organizers that will supplement student learning. Most notably, the Venn diagram is widely used and effective. Also, the use of various charts and webbing has proven to be helpful.



Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class



When connecting this reading to others done in class, one cannot help but notice that chapter three in Marzano’s “Art and Science of Teaching” essentially cut and pasted the same argument for similarities and differences in chapter two here. The same four methods are encouraged: comparing, classifying, creating metaphors, and creating analogies. Also, the Venn diagram, comparison matrix, and webbing are discussed. I also noticed similarities between this strategy and differentiation once more. In student-directed approaches, students are again empowered to make choices, mold the lesson, and guide their learning between one another by sharing ideas. Also, it highlighted again the need for flexibility among teachers. Teachers need to understand what their topic and goal is and the fact that there are multiple avenues that will permit the goal to be achieved.



Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests



In teaching social studies, comparing and contrasting is a tool that has frequently been used by myself and my teachers before me. Although comparing and contrasting seems like a highly simple process, Marzano broke it down to where it needs to be carefully applied. It is going to make me ask more questions like “what specific relationships do I want learned from this lesson?” and “what prior knowledge do my students have on this topic?” These questions will allow me to assess just exactly how big of a role I need to play and what method should be used. For instance, just as at the beginning of the chapter with the Martin Luther King example, if the students have existing knowledge on a popular subject then it would be beneficial to use a higher cognitive method like analogies or metaphors and I would take a teacher-centered role to give them a different perspective and deeper understanding of a topic they’ve discarded as “already learned”.

Thursday, September 9, 2010

Chapter 8 Review

Part 1: Summary
As the title indicates, chapter eight does outline numerous ways of setting objectives and providing feedback. However, the underlying theme in this chapter as I read it was: it’s not what you do or say, it’s how you do it. Of course setting objectives is important but there are different avenues that bring about varying results. Marzano contends that when setting objectives, educators should set them in general terms. The rationale being that when objectives are broad and general, students are able to personalize their own goals that are more specific that are within the framework of learning established by the teacher. When objectives are too narrow, they can have negative effects upon student achievement because it can result in a neglect of supplementary information that is not seen as pertinent. Also, Marzano contends that feedback is important but it needs to be on an explanatory level rather than “yes or no”. Explaining why an answer is right or wrong allows the student to understand the conceptual gap between what is learned and what needs to be learned. Essentially, the student should understand specifically why they are right or wrong. Furthermore, feedback must be given in a timely fashion. If feedback takes too long to reach the student, then forgetfulness sets in and their understanding of the conceptual framework and subsequently the feedback is considerably reduced. Marzano even concludes that student based feedback can be helpful in providing multiple perspectives and stimulate creativity for many students.



Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class

In connecting this reading with other information provided in class, I found three that stand out: the student’s ability to learn extrinsically, the intrinsic world view that students have that effects learning, and the power of differentiation. Students learn extrinsically because we all do have differing world views. Different environments shape different ways of viewing the world. By interacting with other students as Marzano insists with student based feedback, an interchanging of these cultures and ideas do take place and allows outside information to be taken in and digested into their varying world views. These intrinsic world views also greatly affect how learning is done on a student by student basis. When given choices as Marzano discusses in the personalization of goals, students channel that world view based on culture, family, and beliefs. Consequently, with world views being so diverse, it is equally as important for lesson options to match that diversity which brings me to differentiation. By setting broad goals and allowing students to choose their path based on their past, understanding, and culture; students are empowered, take a greater interest in their learning, and increase achievement.



Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
In the spirit of being honest, with my experiences in the classroom, the idea of empowering students to make their own choices has hardly entered into my thinking. However, after reading this chapter, as well as other graduate courses espousing similar views, I do see the merit in these practices. With history/social studies being my background, I can think of several times feeling frustrated having to read a book and write a paper based upon a conclusion already reached by another or forced to take a similar interpretation generated by another historian. In application in my classrooms, I would like to leave open these interpretations to readings, share opinions among diverse students, and allow for students to find their own meanings of causality and periodization in historical events rather than being told prevailing themes.