Monday, October 25, 2010

Chapter 4 Reflection

Bryan Kidd
Strategy Reflection
Marzano Chapter 4
Strategy: Reinforcing Effort and Providing Feedback

Part 1:  Summary

                In chapter four, Marzano outlines the importance of a student’s connection between effort and achievement while also offering effective recognition strategies by teachers.  Generally speaking, students attribute their success in the classroom to either one of four major beliefs: their ability, their effort, other people, or luck.  When students believe that they achieve based upon their own ability, they feel bulletproof and ready to tackle any project.  When they attribute their success to effort, they have something tangible they can use when tackling assignments.  When students believe that other people or luck are the reasons they do well then it can have an obvious negative impact when those students do work on their own.  Marzano particularly gives emphasis on getting students to believe that effort has the biggest impact upon achievement.  Teachers should teach this concept as often as possible.  Through personal stories or through examples, students should regularly be reminded that hard work pays off in the end.  Teachers can talk about it directly or they can get students to track their own increases in effort and success through rubrics and charts.  Concurrently, students should receive recognition regularly when they are successful.  However, as Marzano points out there have been numerous studies that indicate that recognition has a very little and sometimes even negative impact on student achievement.  That is why it is important that teachers do so in appropriate ways.  Rewards do not necessarily negatively impact intrinsic motivation but they are much more effective when they remain attached to some form of standard performance.  Also, students prefer abstract symbolic recognition better than tangible rewards.  Furthermore, praise should be appropriate for the task achieved.  Some students respond negatively what they feel as undeserved praise.

Part 2:  Connection of reading to another reading in class

            Chapter four reminded me a lot of chapter eight in which Marzano talks at length about student feedback as well.  Although it this is a different type of feedback, it reminds me of the importance of constant interaction between the teacher and the students in mostly informal evaluations.  Whether it is advice on how to do better on a certain subject or giving the students proper praise, both are informal assessments designed to foster student motivation and effort.  Essentially, both chapters placed a high emphasis on continual assessments that help guide students and considerable engagement that helps keep students motivated.

Part 3:  Application of reading to my own teaching interests

            I have been in classrooms in which tangible rewards were a lot of fun and it got students engaged in lessons in the moment.  However, once we left class there was no reason or desire to stay engaged in our spare time.  On the other hand, I have been in classes where verbal praise and high expectations generated a desire to remain at an elevated status in the eyes of the professor.  Therefore, in my classrooms I intend to use more abstract verbal praises and essentially set high expectations for my students.  Generally, people tend to rise to the occasion.

1 comment:

  1. I do not think tangible rewards is as bad as what the book makes them out to be. I mean after all as adults most of the things that we do are for tangible rewards. We work everyday for tangible rewards. I do see where praise could be more effective and reasonable in the classroom though.

    ReplyDelete