Bryan Kidd
Strategy Reflection
Marzano Chapter 2
Strategy: Identifying Similarities and Differences
Part 1: Summary
In chapter 2, Marzano discusses the practice of using similarities and differences to increase student knowledge and the various methods used within this practice. By comparing, students understand the parallels and contradictions between things and ideas and come to a better understanding of every variable’s composition. In doing so, Marzano breaks down four ways that students can do this at progressively improving skill sets. Students can begin by simply comparing two things to one another. The next step is classifying things into groups based upon their composition. Students can create metaphors to show patterns between separate topics. Lastly, students can create analogies which identify parallels between concepts. Although there is a plethora of methods within these four categories, they all really fall under two separate approaches: teacher-directed and student-directed. In essence, the teacher will take center stage when he/she has specific relationships that they want their students to know. When findings are broad and ambiguous, the teacher allows students to generate various findings. In using this framework, Marzano insists on the use of several graphic organizers that will supplement student learning. Most notably, the Venn diagram is widely used and effective. Also, the use of various charts and webbing has proven to be helpful.
Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class
When connecting this reading to others done in class, one cannot help but notice that chapter three in Marzano’s “Art and Science of Teaching” essentially cut and pasted the same argument for similarities and differences in chapter two here. The same four methods are encouraged: comparing, classifying, creating metaphors, and creating analogies. Also, the Venn diagram, comparison matrix, and webbing are discussed. I also noticed similarities between this strategy and differentiation once more. In student-directed approaches, students are again empowered to make choices, mold the lesson, and guide their learning between one another by sharing ideas. Also, it highlighted again the need for flexibility among teachers. Teachers need to understand what their topic and goal is and the fact that there are multiple avenues that will permit the goal to be achieved.
Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
In teaching social studies, comparing and contrasting is a tool that has frequently been used by myself and my teachers before me. Although comparing and contrasting seems like a highly simple process, Marzano broke it down to where it needs to be carefully applied. It is going to make me ask more questions like “what specific relationships do I want learned from this lesson?” and “what prior knowledge do my students have on this topic?” These questions will allow me to assess just exactly how big of a role I need to play and what method should be used. For instance, just as at the beginning of the chapter with the Martin Luther King example, if the students have existing knowledge on a popular subject then it would be beneficial to use a higher cognitive method like analogies or metaphors and I would take a teacher-centered role to give them a different perspective and deeper understanding of a topic they’ve discarded as “already learned”.
It is always important to know what preexisting knowledge a student has. Ecspecially in our field because social studies classes vary so much from class to class. Good post.
ReplyDelete