Part 1: Summary
As the title indicates, chapter eight does outline numerous ways of setting objectives and providing feedback. However, the underlying theme in this chapter as I read it was: it’s not what you do or say, it’s how you do it. Of course setting objectives is important but there are different avenues that bring about varying results. Marzano contends that when setting objectives, educators should set them in general terms. The rationale being that when objectives are broad and general, students are able to personalize their own goals that are more specific that are within the framework of learning established by the teacher. When objectives are too narrow, they can have negative effects upon student achievement because it can result in a neglect of supplementary information that is not seen as pertinent. Also, Marzano contends that feedback is important but it needs to be on an explanatory level rather than “yes or no”. Explaining why an answer is right or wrong allows the student to understand the conceptual gap between what is learned and what needs to be learned. Essentially, the student should understand specifically why they are right or wrong. Furthermore, feedback must be given in a timely fashion. If feedback takes too long to reach the student, then forgetfulness sets in and their understanding of the conceptual framework and subsequently the feedback is considerably reduced. Marzano even concludes that student based feedback can be helpful in providing multiple perspectives and stimulate creativity for many students.
Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class
In connecting this reading with other information provided in class, I found three that stand out: the student’s ability to learn extrinsically, the intrinsic world view that students have that effects learning, and the power of differentiation. Students learn extrinsically because we all do have differing world views. Different environments shape different ways of viewing the world. By interacting with other students as Marzano insists with student based feedback, an interchanging of these cultures and ideas do take place and allows outside information to be taken in and digested into their varying world views. These intrinsic world views also greatly affect how learning is done on a student by student basis. When given choices as Marzano discusses in the personalization of goals, students channel that world view based on culture, family, and beliefs. Consequently, with world views being so diverse, it is equally as important for lesson options to match that diversity which brings me to differentiation. By setting broad goals and allowing students to choose their path based on their past, understanding, and culture; students are empowered, take a greater interest in their learning, and increase achievement.
Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
In the spirit of being honest, with my experiences in the classroom, the idea of empowering students to make their own choices has hardly entered into my thinking. However, after reading this chapter, as well as other graduate courses espousing similar views, I do see the merit in these practices. With history/social studies being my background, I can think of several times feeling frustrated having to read a book and write a paper based upon a conclusion already reached by another or forced to take a similar interpretation generated by another historian. In application in my classrooms, I would like to leave open these interpretations to readings, share opinions among diverse students, and allow for students to find their own meanings of causality and periodization in historical events rather than being told prevailing themes.
Empowering students had not entered my thoughts for quite awhile either. When I first heard of it honestly it kinda scared me. Good post.
ReplyDelete